NEWS & ANALYSIS


NLRB Backs Off Nationwide Injunction Bid Against Starbucks

By Beverly Banks

The National Labor Relations Board and Starbucks ended litigation in a Colorado federal court of agency prosecutors' request for a nationwide injunction to stop the coffee chain from firing workers for their union activities.

Starbucks Investor Suit Seems 'Premature,' Court Official Says

By Rachel Riley

A Washington appellate commissioner gave Starbucks another chance to end a shareholder suit accusing the company's leadership of turning a blind eye to union-busting by managers, saying the lawsuit appears "premature" since it mostly relies on unfair labor practice complaints that are still pending.

Starbucks Threatened To Ax Free Tuition, NLRB Judge Says

By Emily Brill

Starbucks told workers in Bellingham, Washington, they would lose access to tuition-free online classes at Arizona State University and potentially higher wages if they unionized, a National Labor Relations Board judge ruled, ordering the company to stop threatening to rescind employees' benefits if they organize.

NLRB Knocks Starbucks For Punishing Ill. Union Backers

By Braden Campbell

Starbucks violated federal labor law by punishing one Illinois worker for missing work to fulfill a National Labor Relations Board subpoena and sending another home for clashing with customers who disrupted a labor protest, the board said Wednesday.

Starbucks Can't Trash Union Pins At Seattle Cafe, NLRB Says

By Beverly Banks

Starbucks must rescind a rule barring the distribution of union materials at a Seattle cafe, the National Labor Relations Board determined, backing an agency judge's conclusions that the coffee giant violated federal labor law by telling workers not to share these items and throwing union pins away.

3rd Circ. Digs Into NLRB's Power To Punish Starbucks

By P.J. D'Annunzio

A Third Circuit panel on Wednesday struggled to find agreement between Starbucks Corp. and the National Labor Relations Board on the scope of the agency's power to penalize companies for violating employees' rights, as it considered the coffee chain's challenge to the agency's penalties over its firing of two unionizing workers.

Ithaca Starbucks Closings Violated Law, NLRB Judge Says

By Law360 Staff

Starbucks violated federal labor law by closing two stores in Ithaca, New York last year in retaliation for workers' union activity, a National Labor Relations Board judge found, rejecting the coffee giant's arguments that the closures were due to staff turnover and recommending that the company be ordered to reopen the locations.

Starbucks Lawfully Denied Transfer Requests, NLRB Says

By Beverly Banks

An agency judge rightly cleared Starbucks of claims that the company unlawfully denied an Illinois employee's bids to transfer stores, the National Labor Relations Board concluded, pointing to evidence that the company blocked one request because of the worker's availability.

Starbucks' Texts About Union Drive Still Coercive, NLRB Says

By Beverly Banks

Starbucks unlawfully texted a worker with questions about union organizing at a Minneapolis cafe, the National Labor Relations Board concluded, nixing the coffee giant's argument that such queries via text message are "inherently less coercive."

Starbucks' Remark On Worker Trustworthiness Found Illegal

By Beverly Banks

A Starbucks manager at a Tennessee cafe illegally told a worker that employees became untrustworthy after union organizing efforts sprang up, a National Labor Relations Board judge ruled, saying a reasonable employee would consider the remarks a threat of retaliation.

Biz Groups Ask To Join Arguments In Starbucks 3rd Circ. Spat

By Beverly Banks

The National Labor Relations Board's order making employers pay for "direct or foreseeable" harms that emanate from federal labor law violations poses "serious constitutional problems," the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other groups contended, submitting an unopposed bid to raise this argument in a Third Circuit case involving Starbucks.

Starbucks' Evidence Spat Challenge Is Untimely, NLRB Says

By Beverly Banks

Starbucks delayed its challenge of an administrative law judge's decision allowing the National Labor Relations Board general counsel to present evidence relevant to an injunction proceeding, a split NLRB panel determined in a case involving claims that the coffee chain illegally suspended workers in South Carolina.

NLRB Drops 2 Injunction Bids Over NY Starbucks Stores

By Beverly Banks

Two New York federal courts approved the dismissal of National Labor Relations Board injunction petitions against Starbucks, following months of discovery disputes between the agency, company and Workers United.

Starbucks' Mounting Labor Violations Show Bias, NLRB Says

By Braden Campbell

Starbucks' growing pile of labor violations betrays the company's hostility toward workers' efforts to organize, the National Labor Relations Board said Wednesday, establishing a presumption that may hurt the company's defense against future claims of anti-union retaliation.

NLRB Judge OKs Deal In Starbucks Virtual Bargaining Case

By Emily Brill

Starbucks has settled accusations that it bargained in bad faith at over 300 stores by refusing to accommodate virtual bargaining sessions, with a National Labor Relations Board judge approving a settlement in which the company and Workers United agreed to "give reasonable consideration" to each other's bargaining method preferences.

Starbucks Says ALJ's Ruling Illegally Limits Employer Speech

By Tim Ryan

Starbucks asked the National Labor Relations Board to review an agency judge's decision finding the company committed numerous labor law violations in response to organizing at its cafes near Phoenix, saying the board's recent decision tightening scrutiny of workplace rules unconstitutionally restricts employer speech.

Starbucks Fights 'Speech-Censoring' NLRB Order At 8th Circ.

By Beverly Banks

The National Labor Relations Board used a "speech-censoring standard" to find a Los Angeles store manager made unlawful comments to a worker about unionization, Starbucks argued to the Eighth Circuit, saying the agency didn't consider evidence about whether employees felt threatened.

Starbucks Attys Asked Lawful Questions, NLRB Judge Says

By Beverly Banks

Attorneys for Starbucks lawfully questioned workers during representation election hearings, a National Labor Relations Board judge ruled, concluding that the inquiries were relevant and evidence doesn't back the claim that the questions tried to uncover the identities of union supporters.

Starbucks Cleared Of Unlawful Subpoena Claims

By Beverly Banks

Starbucks did not violate federal labor law by issuing subpoenas to Workers United and a fired employee in a case involving a now-shuttered Manhattan cafe, a National Labor Relations Board judge ruled, finding the coffee conglomerate's need for recordings and documents outweighed workers' interests.

Starbucks Threatened Loss Of Tuition At NY Cafe, NLRB Says

By Beverly Banks

Starbucks illegally threatened the loss of a free college tuition benefit if workers unionized at a cafe in upstate New York, the National Labor Relations Board determined while affirming an agency judge's finding that the coffee chain's so-called captive audience meetings were lawful.


--Graphics by Ben Jay.