ORDER it is hereby ORDERED as follows: 1. Plaintiff's Motion to Compel CVS (DE 23 ) is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART as set forth in this Order.
2. Plaintiff's Motion to Compel MTH (DE 24 ), as supplemented by DE 30, is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART as set forth in this Order.
3. Within twenty-one (21) days, each Defendant shall serve corrected and supplemental discovery responses that:
a. eliminate incorporated general objections and "subject to" formulations;b. state each remaining request-specific objection with particularity, identify the portion affected, and state whether the response or production is otherwise complete;
c. state expressly whether responsive information or material is being withheld; and
d. provide an adequate privilege log for responsive material actually withheld on privilege or work-product grounds.
4. CVS's objection based on Rule 33(a)(1)'s twenty-five-interrogatory limit is OVERRULED. To the extent MTH continues to maintain corresponding numerical objections in its discovery responses, those objections are also OVERRULED. MTH shall serve interrogatory answers under oath signed by an officer or authorized agent. 5. Defendants shall supplement their responses concerning other products and incidents within the materially pertinent product scope defined in Section III.B and within the geographic and temporal limits stated in the particular discovery request.
6. MTH shall produce the responsive portions of its accessible UL and testing files concerning the subject model as described in Section III.C. MTH shall make reasonable efforts to obtain the identified subject-product manufacturing photographs and testing records and shall describe the results of those efforts in its supplemental response.
7. MTH shall answer Interrogatory No. 15 by providing the subject product's per-unit manufacturing or acquisition cost and wholesale price to CVS. No further relief is warranted concerning CVS's Supplemental Answer to Interrogatory No. 15. CVS shall respond to Request for Production No. 16 by providing the number of subject-model units sold during the five-year period stated in that request. Plaintiff's request for gross-revenue information is otherwise DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
8. CVS shall produce any insurance agreement responsive to Rule 26(a)(1)(A)(iv) that has not already been produced, or state unequivocally that no additional responsive insurance agreement exists.
9. MTH shall supplement its response concerning communications with CVS as provided in Section III.F.
10. The motions are DENIED AS MOOT to the extent complete responsive information or documents have already been produced, provided that the corrected responses identify the production and confirm whether it is complete. The motion is otherwise DENIED as to MTH Request for Production No. 18 because Plaintiff did not separately develop that issue.
11. The Confidentiality Order (DE 18 ) remains in effect and applies to materials produced under this Order.
12. Each side shall bear its own expenses incurred in connection with DE 23 and DE 24 .
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Signed by the Honorable Joseph Dawson, III on 8/3/2026. (lgib, )